This post shares a letter received from the Aussie crook Caroline MacDonald’s lawyers threatening legal action over what they claim is my defamation. In it I lambast them for their foolishness and show that they knew exactly what was going to happen to their request – I would publish it, immediately and in full. Idiots like these goons have never heard of the Streisand Effect. Enjoy!
For the record, the Streisand Effect is loved by dopey lawyers who think they know best and is now well known to be a global phenomena.
Here is their letter, in full, sent and received overnight on Easter Monday 2025. Note this date and time compared to the date and time of publication of the original Messy posts!
Plus also note their attempt to use the copyright act for it not to be published. I don’t care how they try to phrase it, it’s my right to share their words if I want to because they are the ones who claimed defamation and they therefore made it public. Jovan, you sent it to me! Ummm, I think deep down Jovan knew who he was dealing with and that his client was a fool!
My Analysis
NOTICE TO CEASE AND DESIST INTERNET DEFAMATION
Dear Dennis
RE: MACDONALD – PROTECTION OF REPUTATION
We act for Caroline Yvonne Georgia Macdonald and Black Tie group of companies.
Internet defamatory publication
We have been investigating your unwarranted and defamatory attacks against both our client’s business and Ms Macdonald personally, made by you in a form of a derogatory and disparaging texts and comments published on website https://www.dennis.nz/ which is publicly visible in Australia by our client’s associates, business partners, clients, customers and staff members (see attached) … Our client has been in business for many years and has provided her customers with services to their full satisfaction and frequently exceeding expectations. Our client’s customers supplied numerous testimonials describing her highest level of customer satisfaction and experience and some of which have made publicly available on the Internet. Our client has established a well-founded reputation for the quality of her services and your unwarranted actions and baseless accusations have damaged that reputation and adversely affected and continue to affect our client’s businesses. You have personally posted several viciously false, malicious and wilfully misleading comments about our client’s business BBX Australia, Black Tie group of companies and Ms Macdonald personally.
The facts are that defamation requires falsehood (or deception) to exist. Jovan has done this but I don’t. I warn others and I call a spade a spade! Michael was a loud mouth Aussie who ran dodgy businesses. Caroline is a crook. BBX is a fraud.
Black Tie is a more recent entity that has come to my attention from the same set of crooks.
Examples of your defamatory and/or misleading statements include:
• What follows now is an expose – an expose of the worst kind of white-collar criminal that I could conceive of. An entitled ‘Karen’ that is brutal, vicious and heartless in her greed; in her willingness to use everything in her power to get what she wants, regardless of any ethics, laws or others’ wishes or the wants of others around her.
• Michael’s daughters carried on his fraudulent trading in New Zealand with Caroline and her older sister (Magali Russo) having a couple of failed companies here too.
• the Caroline Macdonald I know is an ugly and aggressive con artist; a fraudster with an ego only matched by her greed and abrasiveness.
• Caroline’s true nature can be seen from this recording, basically she’s showing herself to be the bully and crook she really is.
• I also get into the ways that crooks, crims and crazies like Caroline Macdonald use the logical fallacy of an ad hominem attack to try to take the attention off themselves.
Spare me days! And this is all defamation? FFS Jovan get real will yah? Caroline is a crook as many judges, businessmen and women have found out and have said! Just for the record, I’ll make it perfectly clear . . . Caroline MacDonald is a crook!
The above statements, and many others, made in reference to our client are inter alia utterly false and without merit, and they are defamatory per se in that they depict our client as engaging in dishonest, unprofessional, unethical or misleading activities, that violate civil laws and trade practices including Australian Consumer Law and regulations. According to decisions from the NSW Supreme Court (Gacic v John Fairfax Publications Pty Ltd [2013] NSWSC 1920; Obeid v John Fairfax Publications Pty Limited [2006] NSWSC 1059; Crampton v Nugawela [1996] NSWSC 651; Polias v Ryall [2014] NSWSC 1692) you likely have substantial financial liability to Ms Macdonald, for each and every defamatory statements made by you. Your attempts to spread libellous material about our client’s business and Ms Macdonald have caused and continue to cause serious and irreparable detriment to our client, her reputation and her businesses.
Good. Glad that I could have some decent effect on the world!
Our client’s losses include: the lost opportunity to earn income, distress, damage to reputation and vindication of the reputation. Ms Macdonald will not stand by and allow this malicious misconduct to continue.
Now sue me . . . and stop your stupid BS and postulating!
The Requests
We hereby demand that you:
1. Immediately retract from and any of your websites and social networking sites all defamatory and disparaging comments or remarks regarding Ms Macdonald made by you;
2. Immediately cease and desist in publishing (including posting on Internet) defamatory statements about Ms Macdonald, whether the statements are made by you or third parties; and
3. Cause for a written apology to be published on the same media, being website www.dennis.nz , stating that:
a. Ms Macdonald has always been reputable in dealing with you;
b. Ms Macdonald personally always interacted with you in a professional manner; and
c. That you retract any misleading or disparaging comments made against Ms Macdonald
- Sure, but you haven’t shown me anything that is defamatory Jovan.
- Ditto.
- Yes. Prove it and I will correct any error of fact, forthwith as I detail on my terms as detailed and linked from every page and post on my website.
Please note that we do not attempt to restrict legitimate free speech and strongly believe that the Internet is an important medium for dissemination of accurate and truthful information and for fair comment on issues of interest. Your activities, however, unlawfully encroach upon our client’s civil rights pursuant to the Defamation Act 2005 (NSW). This letter puts you on notice that should you refuse, ignore or neglect to fully comply with all our client’s demands listed herein by COB Monday, 28 April 2025, our client will have no choice but to pursue all legal causes of action, including instigating legal proceedings, to protect her interests.
Go for it buddy, but make sure that you get paid in cash not her fraudulent BBX dollars or whatever con she is up to now!
Our client instructed us that she will pursue both compensatory and aggravated damages together with legal costs incurred by her and her businesses as a result of your actions.
I can’t wait, but sadly I suspect that it will take her another couple of years to do the same thing again!
Please be aware that this letter is copyrighted by our legal practice, and you are not authorised to republish it neither in full nor any of its content in any manner. Use of this letter in a posting, in full or in part, will subject you to further legal action.
I reckon Javon is JAFL – Just Another ‘Stupid’ Lawyer!
As I told another lawyer from Govett Quilliam, Paul Franklin, “Toughen up FFS!”
Leave a Reply